The Murder of Ryan Poston: Inside the Case of Shayna Hubers

In the world of true crime, some cases seem almost too surreal to be real. The murder of attorney Ryan Poston by his girlfriend Shayna Hubers is one of them. It’s a story that shocked Kentucky and captivated a nation — not just because of the brutal nature of the crime, but because of what happened in the hours and years that followed.

On the surface, it looked like a tragic act of self-defense. But what unraveled was a deeply disturbing portrait of obsession, control, and premeditated violence.

Who Was Ryan Poston?

Ryan Poston was, by many accounts, the kind of person others admired. At 29, he was already a successful attorney practicing in Highland Heights, Kentucky. Known for his intelligence, charm, and good looks, Ryan had a tight-knit group of friends and a loving family who supported his dreams. He earned his law degree from Northern Kentucky University and had aspirations of eventually becoming a law professor.

He met Shayna Hubers through Facebook in 2011. She was a 19-year-old honors student majoring in psychology at the University of Kentucky. The two quickly became romantically involved. But from the beginning, their relationship was volatile — full of breakups, reconciliations, and emotional chaos.

The Night of the Murder

On the evening of October 12, 2012, Shayna Hubers called 911 from Ryan’s condo in Highland Heights. Her voice was calm, almost eerily so.

"I killed my boyfriend in self-defense," she told the dispatcher.

When police arrived, they found Ryan dead at the scene. He had been shot six times — once in the face, twice in the torso, and three times in the arms. Shayna claimed he had been physically abusive and that she shot him to protect herself during an argument.

But almost immediately, her story began to fall apart.

The Interrogation and Bizarre Behavior

One of the most haunting parts of this case unfolded in the hours after Shayna’s arrest. Left alone in the interrogation room, she was recorded twirling, dancing, and singing. At one point, she looked directly at the mirror and said, "I did it. Yes, I did it. I can’t believe I did that."

She also mused aloud that Ryan had always wanted a nose job — and remarked that she "gave him the nose job he wanted" by shooting him in the face.

This bizarre behavior, combined with the sheer number of shots fired and the forensic evidence, cast serious doubt on her claims of self-defense.

The Trial and Conviction

Shayna Hubers was indicted for murder and stood trial in 2015. Prosecutors painted a picture of a possessive and obsessive woman who couldn't handle the fact that Ryan wanted to break up with her. Just hours before the murder, Ryan had reportedly made plans to go on a date with Miss Ohio — a fact Shayna likely knew.

The prosecution emphasized Shayna’s hundreds of obsessive texts, her erratic behavior, and the calmness with which she reported the killing. The jury deliberated for five hours before finding her guilty. She was sentenced to 40 years in prison.

However, that conviction didn’t stick.

In 2016, a retrial was granted after it was discovered that one of the jurors in the first trial had a prior felony conviction, making them ineligible to serve. In her 2018 retrial, Shayna was again found guilty — this time sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 20 years.

Obsession, Control, and the Search for Justice

The Shayna Hubers case continues to fascinate and disturb. It speaks to the fine line between love and obsession — and how quickly that line can be crossed. In the aftermath of Ryan’s death, his family has worked tirelessly to preserve his memory and advocate for victims’ rights.

Shayna, now serving her sentence, has made numerous appeals and attempted to paint herself as a survivor. But the evidence — and the jury’s repeated verdict — suggests otherwise.

Final Thoughts

In the end, this isn’t just a story about a fatal shooting or a toxic relationship. It’s about how quickly a life can be taken by someone who claims to love you. Ryan Poston’s death was senseless and brutal, and the trial that followed served as a stark reminder of the hidden dangers of manipulation, possessiveness, and unchecked obsession.

For many, the image of Shayna dancing in the interrogation room will forever define this case. But for those who knew and loved Ryan, the focus remains on justice — and the memory of a life full of promise, cut tragically short.

🎥Watch on YouTube

📺 Watch this episode on YouTube: ⁠⁠Click here to watch⁠

New episodes drop throughout the month—turn on notifications so you never miss a case!

🎧 Listen to Suada’s Crime Files on Spotify

Discover chilling true crime stories from around the world — including white collar schemes, shocking disappearances, and headline-making murders.
👉 Click here to listen on Spotify